Sep 1, 2013

Notre Dame v. Temple: The Reesus Begins


Football’s back!  What a glorious time of year, and when the weather cools and the number of hours I spend in front of the television rises, I also find some extra time to get back to writing and analysis.  This year, JLD’s expanding its analysis to include all offensive plays run by Notre Dame and see what, if anything, we can learn from an obsessively detailed analysis of their plays.  Each week I plan to give you a break down of the QB play, the running game, and overall observations regarding the ND offensive game plan. 

I got good feedback on the pieces I did regarding Golson last year, so the idea is to give more of the stats and fewer words….well, at least until something interesting happens.  The Irish are 1-0, and I’m ready to dig right in.  Loudspeaker, please crank up the “Crazy Train”:

No Golson, no problem.  The Reesus has risen, and there’s no better place to start than with TR’s first game line:

Att:  23
Com: 16
Comp. %: 69.6%
Yds:  346
TD:  3
INT: 0
FMB: 0
Sacks: 1
RZ Attempts: 0
Rushes: 0

How much analysis can you give on a near flawless stat line against Temple?  Plus, we all know Tommy Rees is not defined by his stats (he’s defined by his ‘stache)…but if he were, it might look a little something like this:

Rees by Area of Field Thrown to:
Area:
Left
Middle
Right
Air < 10
Air > 10
Attempts:
11
4
8
12
11
Completions:
7
4
5
10
6
Comp. %:
63.6%
100%
62.5%
83.3%
54.5%
Yards:
135
130
81
137
209
TDs:
1
2
0
1
2

Rees’ Deep Throws (> 10 through air) by Area:
Area:
Completions
Attempts:
Percentage:
Left:
2
5
40%
Middle:
3
3
100%
Right:
1
3
33%

Rees by Targeted Position:
Position:
Completions:
Attempts:
Comp. %:
Yards:
TDs:
RB:
3
3
100%
16
0
TE:
1
2
50%
66
1
WR:
12
18
66%
264
2

Rees to Individual Receivers:
Receiver:
Targets:
Completions:
Notes:
Chris Brown
4
3
3/3 on targets to the right.  0/1 on targets to the left.
DaVaris Daniels
5
3
2/4 on targets over 10 yards in the air.
William Fuller
1
0

T.J. Jones
8
6
2/3 on slot bubble screen.

Rees by Line-up Package:
Set:
Completions:
Attempts:
Yards:
TD:
2WR/1RB/2TE
3
3
63
1
3WR/1RB/1TE
10
16
212
1
4WR/0RB/1TE
3
7
71
1

Rees by Down:
Down:
Completions:
Attempts:
Yards:
1st
8
10*
208
2nd
5
6
88
3rd**
3
7
50
* 9/10 first down targets went to WR’s.
** 5/7 4 WR set throws came on third down.

Takeaways:

Quick Reads:  “Turnover Tommy” didn’t show up all game.  His reads were quick and decisive, which led to 0 interceptions and only one sack.  The sack wasn’t even his fault as a missed assignment led to Tommy being taken down WAY easier than he was by SBPD.  The only truly “bad” pass Rees threw occurred in the second quarter on an attempt intended for Troy Niklas.  Watching the replay, it appears Niklas’ feet got tangled with the defender just as he was making his outside cut upsetting the timing.  Dare I say that Tommy Rees made it an entire game without one bad pass?  I’m waiting on the other signs of the apocalypse…

No Tyler Eifert A Positive?:  One of TR’s biggest issues was his propensity to stare down his security blanket or just blatantly throw it to him whether double, triple, or quadruple covered.  Without Tyler Eifert around, it comes as no surprise that the number of TE targets diminished, but there were only 2 TE targets all game.  The TE targets happened on consecutive passes in the second quarter and each occurred out of the 4 WR/1 TE set.  Not the Notre Dame we’ve come accustomed to over the past….well, decade.  While I’m sure some will point to T.J. Jones as Rees’ new security blanket, I’m not sure this is the case.  Three of Jones’ eight targets came on designed slot screens.  Jones set up closest to the tackle and off the line, and they place Niklas between Jones and the wideout.  The first two worked to great effect.  The last resulted in a drop by Jones.  I expect ND to use this formation at Michigan to set up a long throw anticipating UM to bite on ND’s recurrent use of the play this week.  They ran similar screens to Carlisle, Atkinson, and Daniels.  While Jones may get more targets than anyone else, I'm not convinced Jones is the new Eifert.

How Will Rees Respond Under Pressure?:  Temple’s lack of pressure led to a lot of pitch and catch.  Rees very rarely had to progress through his reads.  On his 4 longest passes (the 2 to Daniels, the screen to Jones, and the pass to Niklas) his targeted receiver was also his primary read.  If BK and Chuck Martin can keep it that simple all year, that’d be great, but we all know the defenses will get tougher, and it begins this coming weekend.  I was impressed with Rees’ accuracy the few times he threw the ball down the field, but there’s no doubt that the ability to step into the throws uncontested and his tall receivers going up against overmatched corners made the throws look better than the skill required to execute them. 

It’s the first game and Temple was never expected to pose too much of a threat, so I’m going to keep the analysis short for this week.  Back Tuesday with a breakdown of the running game.

- Moons

Apr 12, 2013

Don't Drop the Ball, Augusta



On a day that so much attention was given to a rules infraction, it’s another rules infraction that everyone should be talking about.

We all know that 14 year old Guan Tianlang, competing at a level far beyond his age, was assessed a 1-stroke penalty for slow play. While basically nobody liked this ruling or agreed with it, it was technically correct.

USGA Rule 26 governs drops when a ball is in a water hazard. Per this rule, a player can replay the shot from “as nearly as possible from the spot from which the original ball was last played.” A player can also go back as far as he’d like keeping the flag and the point where the ball last crossed the margin of the hazard in line.

When Tiger Woods hit his approach into hole 15, his ball caromed off the flagstick and went into the water hazard near the front-left portion of the green. Per Tiger’s post-round comments, he then went back to where he played from, but went 2 yards farther back. When he did this, I tweeted “Whe did TW's ball last cross the margin of the hazard? Near the bleachers. Shouldn't he have dropped on that line, not the line he did?”

Clearly, Tiger could have dropped from his original spot, but admitting that he dropped 2 yards farther back eliminates the “re-hit” drop option from consideration. The only other option he had was to keep the point where the ball last crossed the margin in line with the flag.

As I stated above, the ball bounced off the stick and rolled off the front-left portion of the green and into the hazard. That is the point the ball last crossed the margin of the hazard, and that is the controlling point for the line Tiger needed to take his drop from.

It’s absolutely within the realm of possibility Tiger just assumed his ball crossed the hazard on the line he originally hit it (it did, at first), but that line does not control where you take your drop. Check out the last paragraph of this Rules Decision:

“If a ball last crossed the margin of a water hazard as described in the situation above, it appears that the ball crossed the margin of the hazard three times (e.g., first, the initial time it crossed; second, when it crossed over the hazard onto land; and third, when the ball rolled back into the hazard). So when the Rule states that the ball must be dropped “keeping the point where the ball last crossed the margin of the water hazard directly between the hole and the spot on which the ball is to be dropped,” it is referring to the third (final) time. It is the reference point for the 26-1b option only.” From http://www.usga.org/ourexpertsexplain.aspx?id=2147496891

On a day that rules were being enforced, the Officials might want to go have a look at this one.

Apr 3, 2013

Final Score: Yu Darvish - Good, Houston Astros - Awful


Yu-mania (and all the associated “Yu” puns that go with it) is upon us.  While tensions continue to mount with North Korea, America and its pastime are falling in love with another Asian import, and for once it’s not an electronic product, a car, or this guy.  Major League Baseball has an odd habit of having a big opening day of games followed by a relatively light slate, which was just fine as Yu Darvish’s performance against the Astros was more than enough to captivate all audiences.

The stat line is impressive:  8.2 IP, 0 R, 1 H, 0 BB, 14 K’s. 

Darvish faced twenty-seven batters (we must use the term liberally when referring to the Astros), and it wasn’t until that twenty-seventh man hit a grounder up the middle that Darvish’s bid for the twenty-fourth perfect game in Major League history came an end.  It would have been Mon-Yu-mental…See, it’s just too easy with this guy’s name, and damn is it annoying.  I’ll take the pledge now to avoid anymore awful “Yu” puns. 

Darvish is a trendy pundit selection for A.L. Cy Young coming into the season because: A) He’s on a good team and should get some wins, B) Has a gaudy strikeout rate (2nd in the A.L. in 2012 among qualified starters with a 10.4 K/9 rate), and C) is a classic “I’m smarter than you” pick.  It’s no fun for writers and analysts who follow the game to pick Felix Hernandez (2010 winner), Justin Verlander (2011 winner), or David Price (2012 winner) even though all three of those guys are still in the prime of their career.  That would be so passé.  No, the analysts need to pick someone just slightly off the beaten path (even though that path is paved, well-lit, and privately maintained) because if it hits, the analyst gets to puff their chest and walk around with a smug sense of self-confidence often seen on Fox News shows.  It also helps that Darvish is a very, very good pitcher.

Enter tonight’s start.  The analysts mentioned in the paragraph above love to talk “sample size” and not taking any one start too seriously.  Don’t you dare suggest that spring training darling Yasiel Puig is legit to these guys.  They will figuratively, and if close enough to them in a Home Depot literally, take out their pitchforks and attempt to stab you for suggesting spring training results matter or that 60 at bats have any meaningful correlation to long-term success.  All of that, naturally, goes out the window when discussing their pre-season crush’s start versus the lowly Astros.  Sure, they might pay lip service to “it’s only one start,” but similar to the flow of this sentence their quote too will have a “but” attached to it.  As in:

“It’s only one start, but Darvish was absolutely brilliant tonight.”  Or..

“It’s only one start, but the movement and command of the zone Darvish displayed tonight is why [I] am so excited about him this year.”

To be fair, both of these sentences could be true.  They also contain absolutely no added value because at the end of the day, one game, is one game, is one game.  Since 2000, there have been four perfect games in the American League.  They were thrown by:  Mark Buehrle (2009), Dallas Braden (2010), Phillip Humber (2012), and Felix Hernandez (2012).  Exactly zero of those guys won a Cy Young the same year.  Only Felix Hernandez even received a vote for Cy Young the same year.  Hell, it’d be more correct based on the previous 4 perfect games to assume Yu Darvish was facing the Tampa Bay Rays (3/4 occurred versus the Rays), then to assume this near perfect game is any indicator of Cy Young success.  Of course, this wasn’t a perfect game, and Darvish wasn’t facing the Rays.  Instead, he was facing an Astros team that is more popular than a Yu-Darvish-Cy -Young-prediction to finish with the worst record in baseball this year. 

Were I to have to select between predicting Yu Darvish to win the Cy Young or the Houston Astros to actually be no-hit this year, I’d select the latter.  As a matter of fact, I think the Astros might get no-hit multiple times this year.  I don’t want to pile on the Astros.  This is a team taking a radical, aggressive approach to rebuilding not just their major league team but their entire method of operation.  Short-term be damned. 

In 2012, the Astros led all major league teams with a 22.7 K% by their batters.  Since 2005, only the 2010 Arizona Diamondbacks had a team K% higher than last year’s Astros.  While strikeout loving players like Jordan Schafer and Bryan Bugosevic are no longer getting consistent at-bats, the Astros have added some other impressive human fans to their everyday projections.  Barring injury, the Astros will likely give at least 400-500 at bats to Rick Ankiel (25% career K-rate), Carlos Pena (26.8%), and Chris Carter (32.5%).  Small sample-size recognized, the Astros have struck out on 42.86% of their at bats over these first two games.  The guy the Astros faced in game 1, Matt Harrison, matched a career high with 9 strikeouts in just 5.2 IP.  Harrison has appeared in 127 major league games and has recorded 7 or more strikeouts in only 10 of those appearances.  It was 2011 the last time Harrison recorded 8 or more strikeouts in a single game.

Just before the season began, the Astros trotted out most of their regulars for a spring training game against the Atlanta Braves and faced Braves rookie Julio Teheran.  The line-up for that game varied very little from the one Darvish faced tonight, and the Astros made Teheran a very happy guy by solidifying his place in the Braves rotation after he managed to throw 6 hitless innings while striking out 10.  This Astros team is bad.  Like, real bad.  And they have the potential to be historically bad.  It’s hard to imagine that they will manage to go 160 more games this season without putting up a goose-egg in the hits column over 9 full innings (as opposed to doing it over just 8.2).

Yu Darvish probably just had the best start he’ll have all season versus an awful line-up.  While it’s fair to applaud his efforts, let’s hold-off on passing out the Cy Young ballots just yet, 

Apr 1, 2013

Phil Mickelson: Ph.D or Phraud?

Late last week, Phil Mickelson stated that he had something special in the works for the upcoming Masters Tournament, to be held next at the hallowed grounds of Augusta National Golf Club.

“We have a special club we’re making that I’ll be hitting on Monday,” Mickelson said Friday. “So, we’ll see.”

Today, I got the inside scoop on this “special” club Phil and his Callaway friends are creating. But its uniqueness might not lay in what the club is, but how the club is used.

As most avid golf aficionados know, to excel at Augusta, you must be able to work the ball right-to-left off the tee. Crucial driving holes like 2, 9, 10 and 13 all demand a hard right-to-left ball flight in order to maximize birdie or eagle opportunities. For right-handed players, a hard right-to-left draw will land running and get that extra nudge of distance all golfers want. For Phil, though, being a lefty means on holes like this, his soft fade leaves him at a disadvantage.

“I hate not being the longest guy on those holes. My right-to-left fade just lands too soft and doesn’t run out,” Mickelson lamented today.

As Phil’s popularity has swelled over the past decade plus, Phil’s backstory has also reached the masses. Most people know that Mickelson was born right hand dominant, but learned how to golf left-handed as a way to mirror his father’s right-handed golf swing.

What most people don’t know is that Phil can also swing a pretty smooth stick from the right side of the golf ball.

“The secret club I’ve had Callaway make is a right-handed driver to compliment my strong left-handed 3 wood,” Mickelson explained to a select few reporters. “I’ll just take my normal driver out of the bag next week. We all know there have been a few guys like Notah Begay III that have putted both right and left-handed in competition, but I don’t think anyone has ever tried it on the full swing. I really think being able to rip a draw with my Calaway X-Hot driver right-handed will help me out tremendously at Augusta. This way I can hit a draw from either side of the ball, and hit it farther than everyone else. That’s what I like doing.”

Will this plan be a success for Phil as he tries to win his fourth green jacket, or will it backfire like his ill-fated attempt to play the longest U.S. Open venue in history (Torrey Pines, 2008) without any driver at all? We’ll see, indeed.

*The only quotes actually attributed to Phil Mickelson are what is contained in the second paragraph. The rest of this entry is JLD's attempt at some April Fool's day fun!

Mar 23, 2013

Suing to Gain a Competitive Advantage and Other Non-Sensical Thoughts


John McMickey is a long time Red Sox fan.  I’m sure that’s hard to imagine given his name.  He’s also a huge Dustin Pedroia fan.  During an early September game in 2012, McMickey decided to send Pedroia a quick tweet during the 3rd inning of a match-up with the New York Yankees.  The color commentator for the Red Sox broadcast had just mentioned that Yankees’ starter Ivan Nova was tipping his pitches by changing arm slot whenver he threw his curveball.  McMickey then sent Pedroia a tweet giving him the heads up.

While against club policy to check or send social media during a game, Pedroia by chance had his phone with him on this night.  While waiting to bat in the bottom of the third, he glanced down at his phone after it buzzed in its pocket and saw:  “@BostonMick: Nova tipping pitches.  Arm high on curve.  #homerunacoming!”  Pedroia responded with a quick reply of “thanks brah,” and then promptly went out, waited for Nova’s arm slot to rise, and then deposited a ball over the green monster on a hanging curve.  McMickey was elated, at least until he checked his mail on October 4….

As McMickey sorted through the various mail inserts, credit card applications, and past due bills, one letter got his attention.  It had the name of a law firm in the top left corner, and it seemed to be a fancy law firm (there were at least 5 last names making up the incoherent partnership title!).   As McMickey read the first paragraph, he was stunned.  Major League Baseball was suing him for tortious contract interference.  They claimed he was well aware that there were team policies in place banning social media communications during games, and that information regarding tipping pitches could not be relayed in the real-time format.  They said he was well aware of it citing a 2011 ESPN story.  By sending that tweet to Pedroia, he had enabled Pedroia to break these rules and compromised the integrity of that September game.  McMickey’s jaw dropped…..

If all of this seems outlandish to you, it should.  After all, the entire account is fictional.  However, after this week’s announcement that Major League Baseball has filed suit against Biogenesis for tortious contract interference for the alleged distribution of PED’s to several major league players, maybe the story isn’t that outlandish afterall.  To be clear, I’m not trying to draw a direct parallel between the use of PED’s and pitch stealing (though the causal connection to unfair competitive advantage is similarly nebulous).  Nor am I suggesting that John McMickey’s tweet amounts to the same degree of conduct that Biogenesis is alleged to be involved with.  However, the validity of Major League Baseball’s ficitional law suit against McMickey and its all too real suit against Biogenesis is quite similar:  It’s not.  The major difference between the two is that Biogenesis has information Major League Baseball wants.  McMickey didn’t. 

It doesn’t take a law degree or knowledge of esoteric latin phrases to know that what Major League Baseball is really after is Biogenesis’ transaction ledgers.  Information they’ve, to this point, been frustrated at trying to obtain.  At its core, Major League Baseball isn’t expecting to get any monetary judgment out of a now defunct pain clinic.  Even if they could prove damages, highly suspect in its own rights, a monetary judgment would be less than a drop in the bucket for an organization as large and wealthy as MLB. 

They don’t need to get to that stage.  All MLB’s lawyers need to do is convince a Florida judge that the claims aren’t baseless on their face, avoid the inevitable Motion to Dismiss that the defense will file, and get to the discovery stage of the law suit.  Don’t expect this process to be smooth or quick. 

WHAT ARE THEY FIGHTING FOR?

Realistically, this could take at least six months to a year just for MLB to obtain any of their much sought information.  Even if they do receive it, a proper follow-up investigation and any related grievance proceedings will take even longer.  As has been widely reported, the main targets of all this are Alex Rodriguez and Ryan Braun.  By the time Major League Baseball has enough information to take action against these guys, Alex Rodriguez could be retired.  The seasons implicating Braun could be in the distant past, and the torch of “stardom” may have already been passed to the new generation of guys like Mike Trout and Bryce Harper.  Which leaves the question, what exactly is Major League Baseball fighting for?

In the coming weeks and months there will be a lot of theories about MLB’s end game.  I’m sure Bud Selig and baseball’s higher ups will cite their commitment to the integrity and good will of baseball being their paramount concerns, but the reactionary nature of this process is an exercise in futility.  Failure to contemporaneously punish player PED use leaves baseball looking like nothing more than a scorned lover.  While trying to exact its revenge, baseball will continuously remind everyone that PED’s still make their way into the game.  They’ll tear down the stars and performances that make the game palatable.  What exactly did International Cycling gain by pursuing Lance Armstrong so far after the fact?  Nothing except relegation to a status as an entirely compromised sport.   I suppose that counts as an end game, just not a good one. 

The only thing we know for certain is that this is not a good business move in the foreseeable short-term.  Major League Baseball will likely end up spending hundreds of thousands if not millions of dollars on this process to harm itself.  It would be economically prudent to just let one of these PED fueled players punch Bud Selig in the face.  The result would be the same as the law suit:  Black eye for baseball, diminished reputation for the player. 

IF YOU CAN’T BEAT ‘EM, SUE ‘EM:

There is another perspective to all this legal boxing that needs mention.  Major League Baseball may feel obligated to pursue this lawsuit.  They may feel that in order to honor the terms of the Joint Drug Agreement that they are required to pursue all reasonable measures to uncover violations of the Agreement, and this law suit fits the bill.  Even if nothing comes of it, Major League Baseball can then say “Hey, we did everything we could to stop the abuse.  We tried, so blame the players, not us.”  It’s not a stretch to think that one of Bud Selig’s trusted advisors made this exact point.  “We can win the battle of public opinion about who’s to blame.”

 The problem is baseball is simply trying to save face because they know they’re fighting a losing battle.  Cheaters (if that’s how you perceive them) will always remain a step ahead.  As long as the economic stakes are high enough and a competitive advantage is perceived, some player, somewhere, is still going to try to beat the system.  Baseball can “win” the battle of public opinion and still come out the loser.  When third parties start getting blamed, it’s out of frustration, not commitment to a solution.  This is not just true for professional sports but all walks of life.  Obesity is an issue?  Blame big gulps.  Violence in schools is on the rise.  Blame video games.  The flaw in logic is human nature.  Searching for solutions often leads to ill-advised and resource consuming crusades against speculative “causes” of the problem.  Major League Baseball is just following suit (pun intended). 

By the time this gets settled, which it almost certainly will, baseball will have likely moved onto a more recent crisis of integrity.  Maybe they’ll get what they want, maybe they won’t.  The logic and reason behind all of this may not just be flawed, it may be non-existent.  For now, the only congratulations that go out are to the law firms involved in baseball’s latest crusade, as they’re the only ones who we know for certain will benefit.

Nov 23, 2012

Luck of the Irish? Nope, It's Just College Football


On the eve of what could be an historic Saturday, the skeptics remain.  The team and CBK must have zoned these guys out weeks ago.  Otherwise, they should have no fewer than 39 losses this season.  Given very little credit for their wins, a constant refrain from the “experts” has been about the luck of the Irish (cliché’ intended).  They got “lucky” when the officials decided that there wasn’t enough evidence to rule that Stepfan Taylor made it into the end zone in overtime versus Stanford.  They got “lucky” when Pitt’s kicker missed a 37-yard field.  They got “lucky” for a second time on that play when the refs failed to catch that the Irish had two players on the field wearing the same number.  If it wasn’t for “luck,” so the analysis goes, Notre Dame wouldn’t be relevant on the national stage right now. 

Regardless of luck, Notre Dame remains undefeated and in the driver’s seat headed into the final full slated Saturday of the college football season to reach the national championship.  Some are suggesting the Irish have already received another “lucky” break with Matt Barkley ruled out for USC.  What I find interesting is how the “luck” other teams still in the national title picture have received has apparently been ignored.  No team entirely controls its own destiny.  College football is an ever-changing and often fleeting landscape.  It’s what you do with the opportunities you’re given that define a season.  How have the other national title contenders “lucked” out?  Glad you asked….

#2 Alabama:  The darlings of the SEC have certainly had their share of lucky circumstances to be #2 right now.  This list includes, but is not limited to:

A.  September 15, 2012 - @ Arkansas:  Sure, the Crimson Tide rolled the Razorbacks beating them 52-0.  There was nothing lucky about the score.  However, how much did Alabama have to do with not one but two head coaches for Arkansas personally imploding.  Bobby Petrino had the Razorbacks in great shape by the end of the 2011 season, and with quarterback Tyler Wilson deciding to return, there was more than one pundit proclaiming that Arkansas might take the next step this year.  A motorcycle accident for Petrino unraveled into a scandal involving a young female that cost Petrino his job.  On short notice, Arkansas went with a nice guy who was available…John L. Smith.  That has not worked out very well.

As for Tyler Wilson, a trendy pre-season Heisman selection, well, he didn’t play at all having suffered a concussion the previous week.  Alabama did absolutely nothing to deserve any of these breaks.  How lucky….

B.  November 3, 2012 - @ LSU:  Another game the Tide could easily have been on the losing end of.  Inexplicable defensive play calling and clock management permitted Alabama to concot a go-ahead drive with under 2 minutes left in the game and then face 3 plays worthy of a high school football team to end the game.  Yes, A.J. McCarron deserves some credit, but how LSU let a the Tide complete 3 straight passes of 10+ yards to the same receiver and then let a screen play go for 28-yards and the game winning touchdown is more than just talent…..it was darn lucky.

C.  November 17, 2012:  While Alabama beat up on FCS foe (yes, FCS foe) Western Carolina, other things fell just how they needed to to get Alabama back into the discussion.  Having lost the week before, Alabama deserved to lose control of their destiny, and yet the decision to enjoy a cupcake on the week that several others had to battle and fight paid off in a substantial way. 

Alabama’s a very good team, and I have no issue with them enjoying a second shot at getting to the NTG, but you’ll have to excuse me if I don’t believe that a few “lucky” breaks fell the Crimson Tide’s way as well.

#3 Georgia:  Georgia has defeated exactly one ranked team this year.  That was the always chippy and very frequently poorly played Largest Outdoor Cocktail Party game versus Florida.  Georgia got blown out by South Carolina 35-7 in their only other game versus a ranked opponent.  Fortunately for the Bulldogs, that game happened early enough in the season to give the Dawgs time to recover. 

Just as fortunately for the Bulldogs, South Carolina would follow up that dominating performance with two straight losses giving UGA an opportunity to play in the SEC Championship game.  If Georgia didn’t have one more premiere game on their schedule, they wouldn’t be in a position to knock of Alabama and make it to Miami.  They had nothing to do with Carolina’s losses or their weak-ish schedule (Don’t the Irish get blamed for having a schedule that didn’t live up to hype??), but now they also control their own fate.

By the way, wasn’t Mark Richt supposed to be fired by now if the UGA fan base had their way?

#4 Florida: 

Before I even get into the nuances of what needs to happen tomorrow to get Florida to the game, didn’t I just say they lost a sloppy game to Georgia?  Why yes, yes I did.  Florida to their credit has faced a very difficult schedule this year, but it hasn’t been without it’s share of breaks.

I can’t help but go back to their September 8, 2012 game versus Texas A & M.  It was a game they won 20-17, but how fortunate was it that they faced Johnny Manziel, the now Heisman front-runner, in his very first collegiate start?  Florida had to go into a hostile environment in College Station, and the Aggies certainly had a lot to play for with College Gameday on campus and it being their first ever SEC game.  However, you get the sense based on the direction the Gators have gone (ummm…is stagnant a direction?), and the direction that Johnny Football has gone that the result in a rematch might have been markedly different.  Is that a guarantee?  Nope.  But, if we’re talking about “luck,” it was certainly more a scheduling quirk that Manziel had yet to hit his stride in first year coach Kevin Sumlin’s system.

Speaking of scheduling quirks, how about Florida’s win over South Carolina?  When I look at the box score, there is an important name missing from Carolina’s offense:  Marcus Lattimore.  A hip injury limited him to just 3 carries for the entire game.  Lattimore might mean more to the Gamecocks than Barkley means to USC, and yet, it seems almost forgotten that Florida’s win came on a day that South Carolina lacked their biggest difference-maker.

All of that leads into this Saturday.  Yes, the Gators to have any shot will have to beat a very good FSU team.  However, they also need to bank on Notre Dame losing.  Under those circumstances (Beat FSU, ND loss), Florida would almost be assured a spot in the title game regardless of the outcome of the SEC Championship.  And therein lies the problem.  Under those circumstances, Florida could become the second straight SEC team to make the NTG without even making its own conference championship.  They will, in effect, benefit from being idle.  I’m not here to rail on the SEC, but anytime a team making the NTG does not even play in their own conference title game (when one exists) a good deal of “luck” exists.

#5 Oregon:  Oregon has generally killed the opposition in its way.  In that respect, there’s no game to point to to call them “lucky.”  Their “luck” exists in that they are the team who lost most recently this season that still possesses a legitimate shot at reaching Miami.

It’s not often that you can lose as late as November 17 and still entertain any shot at reaching the ultimate game of the season.  Additionally, it’s not guaranteed that Oregon will reach its conference championship game either.  Stanford must lose this Saturday to UCLA.  Otherwise, Oregon will remain idle for the final regular season weekend, and Stanford and UCLA will play two consecutive weeks.

Oregon has 0 wins versus an opponent currently ranked in the top 20 in BCS standings (Notre Dame has 3:  Stanford, Oklahoma, Michigan), and their one chance to add to that total (this weekend versus Oregon State) could end up knocking the Beavers out of the top 20 as well.  More than any of the other competitors, the Ducks have beaten up on the weak while avoiding major encounters.  While it might be a formula for double-digit wins, a return to the BCS Championship game would be nothing short of “lucky.”

As I said at the outset, it’s a matter of taking advantage of the opportunities your team is given.  However, can we please stop with the Irish are lucky headline and realize that every team in the National Title hunt has had its share of luck this year.

Nov 21, 2012

One Moment: KLM Defines ND's Season


In a season that has exceeded all expectations trying to redact down the season to a defining moment seems like an exercise in futility.  Notre Dame came into the season facing what most “experts” (that’s now their official title:  “experts”  as I refuse to acknowledge them as anything further given their reluctance to accept ND’s actual on-field performance compared to perceived value) perceived as an impossible task.  Let’s be fair.  As this season got underway, I proclaimed that I would have no expectations for the season.  What body of evidence did I have to work with??  Ridiculous schedule, first year starter at quarterback, and far too many unknowns in the secondary to feel otherwise.  Plus, our beast on the d-line, Aaron Lynch, had waffled yet again and left us after just one year. 

As the season revealed itself, there are many, many moments that could be pointed to as the defining moment of a special season.  Was it the Tommy Rees drive in the Purdue game?  The four down, goal-to-go stand versus Stanford?  The 50-yard bomb to Chris Brown at Oklahoma?  What about the magic of a frantic comeback versus Pitt that included their kicker missing a 37-yard field goal?  I’d entertain any of these on field moments as being the most important, and that’s just what I’m remembering off the top of my head.  However, for me, there was one moment that occurred on the sidelines that told me something new was happening in South Bend.

The phrase “trap game” gets thrown around liberally in college football.  In the one sport where the regular season is of paramount importance, every game is potentially a trap game.  Every team is always looking to make a statement on any given week, and when it comes to teams coming to Notre Dame Stadium, it’s even more magnified.  For visiting teams, a chance to beat Notre Dame in South Bend is always a circled game on the calendar.  Sadly, in recent years, ND’s been far to accommodating a host for these desires. 

Welcome to the BYU game, and my choice for defining moment of the season.  What I’m about to describe is not related to an on-field moment but rather what happened following a mistake by Notre Dame.  While I’m sure there’ll be criticism of my choice, what transpired is what let me know that the culture of Notre Dame football had changed, and for once, it was in a positive way.

Setting the Stage:

The Irish came into the October 20, 2012 contest against BYU having just survived a brutal, memorable encounter with Stanford.  The Stanford game was defined by its physicality.  An unfortunate (and really, the only unfortunate) side note to come out of the Stanford game was Everett Golson’s concussion sustained late in the fourth quarter.  In a contest won in overtime after an epic goal line stand, it’s understandable why ND might not have been completely ready for another physical opponent like BYU.  The team, despite CBK’s desire to focus on the current game, could not have possibly been completely forgetting that a win this week would set up a chance to go in undefeated to Norman, OK. 

The result was a flat performance from the outset.  In fairness, Rees at his essence is a game manager.  BYU was ready to play, and their style was surely going to be a hurdle for a team that had just come off of facing one of the most physical teams in the nation.  While Notre Dame managed to score a TD in the first quarter, the offense was more or less stuck in neutral.  Poor execution and lacking the creativity that Golson brings all were keeping the game closer than need be.

As the game entered the second quarter, Notre Dame possessed a 7-0 lead, though it didn’t feel like a lead at all.  On ND’s first possession of the second quarter, the team had a chance to perhaps extend the lead when they started a possession on their 19-yard line.  Just after Theo Riddick converted a 3rd and 1 to extend the drive, the team had a first down on their own 29 when the following occurred…..

The Moment:

As the Riddick run ended, sophomore tight end Troy Niklas inexplicably slapped a BYU defender in the helmet prompting a personal foul penalty for a late hit.  The team was now backed up to its own 15, and dumb penalties appeared to continue to be the ND calling card.  Was this somehow a flashback to the 2011 season?  What in the World was Niklas thinking?? 

Understandably, CBK removed Niklas from the game for the time being.  As he ran off to the sideline, there was no blow up by Kelly, a sight which most of us had become accustomed to.  No purple face.  No loss of composure.  Kelly seemed more in control than he had in season’s past and just wanted to remove a player from the game who’d lost grasp on what was going on.

Then, NBC (to their credit) panned to the sidelines to find the offender Niklas.  Generally, this is a shot of the player sitting on a bench somewhere by himself as the team continues on, but something very different was displayed.  Instead of sulking, NBC caught Niklas being talked to by Kapron Lewis-Moore (KLM or “Kappy”).  KLM was not berating Niklas. Instead, you could see him talking to Niklas.  This was a learning moment for the very talented sophomore.  His senior captain teammate was not looking to embarrass him.  As all of this was unfolding, the following text exchange happened between BH and I:

BH:  Jesus f--- how many dumb f---ing penalties can we have this year?

Moons:  I really like though that Kelly went and pulled him, and then you see KLM over there getting him straight.  There’s an actual hierarchy and respect going on with these guys.

BH:  Yes there really is

It’s understated.  It’s subtle.  Heck, less than ten plays later Mathias Farley would get pegged for a late hit out of bounds, but the import cannot be understated.  Leadership was present on the sidelines.  Just the previous season, one riddled with inexcusable mistakes and more than one Kelly blow up, the team had rotated captains all too frequently.  This season, Kelly named four to represent his team and assume a leadership role.

The second-quarter didn’t get better, and in fact, BYU would lead 14-7 at half over the Irish.  However, that single interaction between Kappy and Niklas underlined an important dynamic shift in this team.  Everyone was buying in.  Everyone understood their role on the team.  It was a moment of leadership that transcended position (TE) and squad (Offense vs. Defense) affiliations.  This was a team united to win and had the leadership in place to overcome fallacies.  I don’t know what KLM said to Niklas on the sidelines, but what I do know was I didn’t see a team struggling with inner-turmoil.  No, they were going to take this opportunity to learn and improve and do it without a sense of impending doom.

The Impact:

Understandably, Manti Te’o has garnered much of the praise for the increased leadership this year.  Te’o is a unique individual whose maturity and passion surpasses his age by an exponential margin.  The problem (being liberal with the use of the word problem) is that not many people have the ability to operate at that level.  Te’o’s a guy who wears his emotion and passion openly.  I’m nearly a decade his senior and don’t possess that type of commitment.  While I’m sure he inspires, I somehow doubt he’s relatable on a day-to-day basis.  His qualities are innate, unique, and, for lack of a better term, “special.”  I’m sure he will succeed at whatever he decides to do.

Watching the NBC special on a Week in the Life of the ND Program, what I was most struck by was KLM’s leadership.  He’s a beacon of positivity and is clearly someone that the entire team likes and respects.  While others will pile on the praise of Te’o for good reason, it’s a guy like Kappy that more closely personifies the culture shift at Notre Dame.  This group of seniors has implemented a serious culture shift.  The seniors were not recruited by Kelly and his staff but instead by Weis.  They dealt with Kelly’s ill-stated remarks about “his guys” versus the others, and yet somewhere along the way this team gelled into a cohesive unit.

It’s a tribute to the senior leadership for making that occur.  For everything that might be said about the Charlie Weis tenure,  we should give him credit for recruiting such high quality individuals.  In many senses, it’s what Notre Dame is all about.  Players who come to Notre Dame do so because of the entirety of the experience they can realize in South Bend.  It’s not all about football.  It’s about becoming a better person.  It’s about achieving something collectively that cannot be accomplished on an individual basis.  Selfish players will not thrive in the Notre Dame system, and the ND community wouldn’t have it any other way.  The seniors on the team could have easily justified being somewhat apathetic to the overall team goals.  After all, this wasn’t supposed to be a great year.  They could have justified it because they weren’t Kelly’s guys.  Instead, they embraced the role of team leaders, and the impact has been felt throughout the program. 

If we look back two to three years from now and the Notre Dame program is thriving again, I hope we as a fan base are smart enough to appreciate what occurred this year.  Yes, the ultimate goal is in sight, but it’s not determinative.  Regardless of the outcome of the USC and BCS game (no matter which it is), this year has been a success.  It’s a success because the culture has shifted at ND.  No longer is the program about whom to blame.  Instead, the program is about progressing.  The seniors on this team have made that happen.  Kappy in particular in my eyes is so important to this progression.  The quality and style of team leadership displayed by KLM lets me know that the example has been set.  Having individuals of his quality…and Te’o’s quality…and Zach Martin’s quality…and Tyler Eifert’s quality is part of the reason I am proud to call myself an Irish alumni. 

I couldn’t be prouder of this group of men, and I recognize that they’re already better individuals than myself.  For me, nothing demonstrated the culture shift in Notre Dame football better than this singular moment, and with that I leave you with one final thought……Beat USC!  No group of men deserves it more than these guys.