Nov 6, 2012

Golson's Progress: Part 1


As we hit the three-quarter mark, there are many things that Irish nation will be talking about.  Yes, “can we go to the national title game?” is an important question.  Same holds true for Te’o’s Heisman chances and our ability to go undefeated.  A majority of these questions hinge on the arm of Everett Golson.  For better or worse, he’s the leader of our offense right now.  JLD has taken time to do some pain-staking research to ask the question:  Is he progressing?  For a redshirt freshman getting his first opportunity on a big stage, this is not an easy question to answer.  We’ve all heard the clichés that young players have ebbs and flows.  JLD will be taking a 4-part look at Golson by evaluating each and every throw he’s made this season.  Honestly, I have no idea what to expect.  I’ll be doing this real time with the rest of y’all, and I am not intending to sugar coat the data in any form. 

The stats are derived from my personal review of every throw Golson’s made as well as ESPN’s stats.  For the first of the four-part series, we’re taking a look at Golson’s first three games as a starter:  Navy, Purdue, and Michigan State.  We should expect to see progress as this goes along, but again, my goal is not to modify the data or skew it in any form.  I want to let it speak to whatever it means.  There are a myriad of other categories I could have considered, and for anyone interested, please let me know by e-mailing me at JLDthoughts@gmail.com, and I’d be happy to lend you my data set.  Let’s see what develops.

First, the base line stats for the first three games:

Attempts:  81
Completions: 47
Completion Percentage:  58%
TD’s:  3
INT’s:  1

We need to break this down in numerous capacities to get a truer picture.  Let’s first take a glance at how Golson’s performed on a down-by-down basis:

Down:
Attempts:
Completions:
Comp. Percent.
TD’s:
INT:
1
37
19
51%
0
0
2
28
19
68%
2
1
3
16
9
56%
1
0
4
0
0
0%
0
0

One trend that became apparent just by tracking the stats was that Kelly is much more likely to let Golson throw on first down.  I can’t explain this in any meaningful way.  It’s simply a pattern.  However, 47% of Golson’s pass attempts came on first down through the first 3 games.  Whether this trend continues remains to be seen, but my first inclination is to think that Kelly felt more comfortable letting Golson take his passing attempts early and then leaving enough time to adjust if it went sour.  Save a few drives, there were few times that a first down incompletion led to Golson attempting a pass on second down.  Another interesting note (though you won’t see a chart about it), 73% of Golson’s passing attempts occurred on Notre Dame’s side of the field.  My guess is Kelly and Chuck Martin’s philosophy was to attempt to use the pass to get the team in a better position to score and then go to the running game when it mattered most.

Of course, first downs are a somewhat neutral proposition.  While getting positive yardage is always important, it’s what you do with 2nd and 3rd downs that matters in order to keep a drive alive.  From the chart above, it’s apparent that Golson was more effective on both 2nd and 3rd downs in terms of completion percentage.  Perhaps defenses were giving up a larger buffer?  For my next chart, I wanted to see the breakdown of how Golson performed on down and distance following 1st down:

Down:
Attempts:
Completions:
Comp. Percent.
TD’s:
INT:
2nd 5+
23
17
74%
1
1
2nd <5
5
2
40%
1
0
3rd 5+
14
8
57%
0
0
3rd <5
2
1
50%
1
0

I would love to know what the national average is for 2nd and 5+ yards is.  However, I do not have the manpower to do so.  What I do know is that Golson saw an incredible spike in completion percentage on second and long.  Intuitively, I’d say this is the result of teams being more willing to give up underneath coverage in order to avoid a first down.  That seems like a fair proposition.  It’s even more fair given Notre Dame’s use of bubble and slip screens to receivers, but still, Golson even in the early going did a great job of at least putting Notre Dame in a third and manageable.  Speaking of distance on the pass, that gets me to my next chart (mmmm…..charts.). 

It’s not just down and distance that matters, it’s also the style of throw.  Defenses are generally willing to allow more underneath throws, and Notre Dame was heavy on those throws through the first few weeks.  Here’s a breakdown by whether Golson threw the ball 10 or more yards through the air (throw aways excluded):

Length:
Attempts:
Completions:
Comp. Percent.
TD’s
INT:
< 10
51
35
68%
2
0
10+
26
12
46%
1
1

66% of Golson’s in play throws were intended for targets 10 yards or fewer from the line of scrimmage.  Clearly, Kelly was trying to protect his young QB in the early going by providing him quick, reliable targets.  Down field throws were not intended to be part of the game except to mix up the defense and provide a change of pace.  This is not a bad thing given the strength of opponent.  Versus teams like Navy, Purdue, and Sparty, the objective of keeping the chains moving is a good one.  Moreover, most of the coverage reads for Golson were very, very easy.  He was being used as a facilitator to get the ball to the playmakers.  God willing, this early game planning will pay off when we face a team like USC that also enjoys quick strikes to get the ball to their playmakers.

Assessing Golson’s throws by target position is also necessary.  Coming into the season, the thought was that Eifert would be the primary receiver, but I think the next table will show that even in the early going when we thought Eiffert was more important, a different tendency might actually develop:

Target:
Attempts:
Completions:
Comp. Percent.
TD’s:
INT:
WR:
39
27
69%
2
1
RB:
15
9
60%
0
0
TE:
23
11
48%
1
0

Despite the preconceptions about ND’s passing game, Golson (at least early on) showed a propensity to throw balls to his receivers.  Nearly half of Golson’s attempts were intended for his receiving corp.  Many of these throws were short slip screens and short passes to either T.J. Jones or Robby Toma. 

Another observation from Golson’s receiver pass attempts:  Davaris Daniels has the chance to be a HUGE weapon for the Irish.  On more than one occasion (and more going forward), it’s Daniels’ big body down the field that provided the most agreeable target to Golson.

Yes, Jones and Toma gobbled up the short grabs, but my impression is that Golson looks for Daniels first.  It makes sense.  They were apart of the same recruiting class, and given that both spent a large amount of time on the sidelines last year together, it would not surprise me if they brokered some sort of relationship.  Daniels’ big body and relative speed give him the outside shot of becoming a Michael Floyd-Lite in the next couple of years. 

Given that the vast majority of Golson’s targets (and successful completions) went to WR’s, it’s also worth exploring how those completions came to be:


Target Dist.:
Attempts:
Completions:
Comp. Percent.
TD’s:
INT:
+10
12
6
50%
1
0
< 10
27
21
78%
1
0


As my final chart of the evening indicates, most of the throws were under ten-yards.  Kelly was definitely protecting Golson at this point .  These numbers spiked in large part because of the considerable number of screens and underneath routes that Robby Toma ran, particularly in the MSU game.  Toma and Jones have been the primary underneath weapons from the beginning of the season.  Anecdotally, I expect this trend to continue as I watch the remainder of the games.

In conclusion, for this first part, it appears the game plan was to have Golson throw 1) early in the down count, 2) underneath the coverage, and 3) to his receivers.  Before I leave off for the night, a few closing thoughts more generally:

1.  Everett Golson threw the ball away 4 times total.  None versus Navy, 1 versus Purdue, and 3 versus Sparty.  Golson’s first instinct in pressure situations is to run.  However, at least at this point of the season, he was not willing to throw the ball away.  It’ll be interesting to see how that develops as I watch more games.

2.  A buddy of mine, JD, posed the question about Golson’s zone reading.  At least through game 3, it appears Golson was asked to do little to any actual read on the defense.  He ran very few times on anything that could remotely be perceived as a zone read.  Instead, it appeared to be either pre-determined to be a run or a pass.  The zone fake was used as the primary playaction weapon but with very little regard to any actual read. 

3.  KeVirae Russell got burned multiple times.   What I already know to be his progress is nothing short of remarkable.  His instincts and sheer athletic ability give him a very, very bright future.  You can see his progression on a week-to-week basis, which is incredibly rare for a true freshman playing out of position.

4  While much attention has been given to Te’o and Tuitt (and with good reason) from the outset, it is apparent the defensive MVP is Nix.  The amount of disruption and/or chaos/attention he demands on the inside is the cog that makes the rest go.  No, he won’t have huge stats at any point this season, but if we’re judging from week-one on, Nix is the clear defensive MVP.

5.  Neal’s role has become more and more limited.  He went from having 3-4 plays in week one that were designed for him on offense to one in week two, and virtually nothing since then.  Much has been made about ND’s Special Teams this year, and Neal’s early season troubles I think play into that more than we’ve considered.  Without devastating results, Neal made several poor choices on punt return work during the first few games, and my impression is that Kelly stopped all of that.  I don’t love wasting a year of Neal’s eligibility given his limited role, but in light of how he performed in the early going, I now have a greater appreciation to why we’ve scaled back our S.T. even further.  While those of us who have watched this part of the team become an eye sore beg for something different, Neal’s mental lapses cannot be ignored.  Without knowing, I can only assume that Kelly has erred on the side of being too conservative in an effort to avoid the calamity that comes with a truly atrocious S.T. play.  It needs to be corrected…

Nov 4, 2012

Re-Casting Rudy: 2012 Irish Season Edition



Is this season starting to feel like a movie script or what???  As the Notre Dame-Pitt game unfolded, I am convinced my heart stopped no fewer than 4 times.  If this season was a movie, I was starting to think it was a horror story….and one of those horribly slow developing ones where for a long time you don’t even know it’s a horror film, and then some shadowy presence does something to the family dog who just won’t stop barking letting you know something really, really bad’s gonna happen.  Yeah, that’s what I was pretty sure I was watching on Saturday.

And then, things changed.  Could this be a story of hope?  Painful, insufferable, if-this-doesn’t-actually-come-true-I’m-going-to-be-devasted-hope??  I mean, the team battled so hard.  Yeah, there were some setbacks, some miscues, but they were going to pull through, right??  You’ve just gotta keep believing.  Holy shit, we just fumbled the fall on the goal line and now Pitt’s got a 30-something yard field goal to win it??  How can this be?  This isn’t the ending, is it?  They missed!!  We’ve still got a chance!!  We’ve gotta score now,  Billy.

Now, I know I’ve seen this script somewhere before.  Overcoming unbelievable odds, the little guy no one respects and refuses to believe in except for himself, epic, inspirational finish….It’s Rudy!  And, what’s this NBC preview following the Breeder’s Cup tonight at 9, you’re showing Rudy!  What a bold gambit NBC.  Doubling down on inspirational stories involving Notre Dame football.  You’ve reeled me in good tonight.

So, instead of even attempting to dissect that ridiculous football game, I’ve decided to re-cast the movie of Rudy using figures from this year’s Notre Dame story.  Cue Rudy theme-music and get yourself a box of tissues ‘cause here we go:

Rudy Ruettiger – Everett Golson:  This part was tailor-made to be Tommy Rees, right?  Unathletic white guy, written off by the fans, pundits, and coaches alike.  Overcoming somewhat self-inflicted plight.  Rudy by deciding to both A) go to Notre Dame despite by all accounts being a “C” student, and B) playing football for the team without athletic skill.  Rees by A) trying to reclaim a meaningful spot after being the opposing teams’ collective MVP last season and getting arrested, and B) playing football for the team without athletic skill.  However, I just couldn’t do it.  Nope.  I was all onboard until Rees threw that unforgiveable pick in the 3rd quarter against the Panthers.  No, I still had residual distaste for this guy, and damnit, you can’t invoke any negative feelings in my soul if you’re going to play Rudy.

Enter Everett Golson.  Everytime he gets knocked down or pulled from a game you can just see him propelling himself back to his feet and saying “I can do it coach.”  Finally, Brian Kelly followed the script and said: “Oh yeah?  Well show me.”  And boom!  Cinematic magic.  Even the late interception that seemed to doom us is just part of the script.  It was the equivalent of Rudy giving up after seeing the dress list for the final game and thinking there was no more hope.  That defensive three-and-out?  That was the team trotting into Dan Devine’s office and telling coach to let Rudy dress in their place.

As Golson crossed the goal-line on that the two-point attempt after the scramble, if you weren’t hearing the crescendo of the theme song from when Rudy records his sack, then I have to believe you’re deaf.  I sure as heck heard it.  Who’s the wild man now??

Pete – Lou Holtz:  Probably the easiest call of all casting.  The loyal to a fault best friend who just tells Rudy to go for it regardless of what everyone else is saying.  Sure, Lou says all of this in a lispier voice, but the sentiment’s the same.  Much like Pete was willing to go ahead and buy Rudy a letter jacket before he ever got into the school, Lou’s always been willing to return Notre Dame to prominence before we’ve proven it.  Pete’s best line in the movie: “Having dreams is what makes life tolerable.”  Lou’s speech to the students following his final game as head coach in 1996 included the line:  “Believe in your dreams.  Follow them.  Pursue them.”  Coincidence?  I think not.

D-Bob – Bob Stoops and Oklahoma:  I’ll admit, that doesn’t sound right.  I mean, D-Bob was Rudy’s only real friend at Notre Dame, but hear me out.  D-Bob really just wanted to use Rudy at the beginning.  Rudy seemed weak, easily manipulated, and damn it, maybe he could help D-Bob meet some girls.  As time went on, D-Bob and Rudy both became mutually useful to one another and a real fondness developed.  When Bob and OU put ND on the schedule, you know somewhere deep down inside they wanted to just use ND’s name brand to put a “big game” on the schedule.  But Bob figured Notre Dame would be weak, easily handled, and might help OU get the attention of some ladies (The pollsters and BCS committee).  Now, as the season has gone along, Notre Dame needs OU to be good to bolster their strength of schedule.  OU similarly needs ND to stay at or near the top as it tries to scratch and claw its way back into a BCS at-large shot.  Plus, I mean, “D-Bob”…”Big Game Bob.”  They both end in Bob.

Daniel Ruettiger (Rudy’s Dad) – Rick Reilly:  Old, experienced, practical and rational about the ways of the World.  Wants Rudy to realize he’s not special and just needs to go to the steel mill like everyone else.  Rudy’s dad and Rick Reilly share all of these (self-imposed) qualities.  Sure, Rudy genuinely wanted to make his dad proud.  Dutifully bringing home his report card from junior college to show his progress.  The real life story might be driven more by spite than by desire for validation from the source, but if things keep going as they are, when we dress for the big game, we’d more than want to call up Rick and tell him we want him at the game.  If he seems reluctant, we’ll talk to…..

Frank Ruettiger – Mark May:  Arrogant.  Thinks he’s better than Rudy.  Constantly tries to put him down with condescending little snipes.  Won’t believe in Rudy no matter what he’s told.  Played football and thinks he knows what it takes to be good and doesn’t believe Rudy possesses the requisite skills.  Has a certain amount of distaste for Pete for fueling Rudy’s optimism.  Sound like anyone?  And oh yes, in that emotional climax of the movie, we’d all like to look over at Mark May timidly holding up one-finger and whispering “that’s right, you’re number 1.”

Fortune (The wise grounds keeper) – Mike Golic:  I don’t love this selection but couldn’t think of who this should be.  Like Fortune, Golic’s a former player with ongoing ties to the university.  Fortune quietly encourages Rudy but through a tough-love sort of relationship.  Doesn’t like thank yous but respects the hell out of Rudy.  He’s also got by far the most memorable quote of the movie:  “You’re five foot nothing.  A hundred and nothing.  And you have barely a speck of athletic ability.  And you hung in there with the best college football players in the land for two years….”  I’m pretty sure Golic gave this speech (in a somewhat mocking manner) no less than 2,344 times after ND beat Oklahoma to retort all of the ESPN analysts who didn’t give the Irish a chance.

No, Golic’s not exactly silent.  Having a radio show would make that somewhat difficult.  A radio show featuring Fortune would be less interesting than the third presidential debate.  However, Golic has through the years had a sort of tough love relationship with the Irish because he does care for them and was very tired of having to take everyone else at ESPN’s grief.  You can also see his spirit returning as a result of the Rudy story.

I’m open to suggestions on changing this one though….

Father Cavanaugh – Brian Kelly:  What?  BK’s not Ara????  How can this be?  In the story of Rudy, it’s Father Cavanaugh who gives Rudy his chance by getting him into Holy Cross.  Believes in Rudy, but isn’t really sure how far he can go.  He tells Rudy, he can get him one semester.  If he does well, then he can get another, and if he does well enough, then maybe…just maybe he has a slight chance of possibly achieving his dream.  It sounds a whole lot like the speeches of BK this year following every game. 

After the Pitt game, Kelly left it in no certain terms that he does not pay attention to what the teams above him are doing because he can’t control it.  May I suggest he change his response to:

“I have only come up with two hard incontrovertible facts:  there is a God, and I’m not him.”  Then, the transformation would be complete.

Roland Steele – Manti Te’o:  Captain of the team.  Admires hard-work.  Inspirational and emotional leader.  Defensive badass.  Would make just about any sacrifice to give Rudy his shot.  That’s all that needs to be said.

Mary – Michigan:  Thinks she’s all that.   Kind of appreciates Rudy’s enthusiasm and passion for football, but is pretty quick to kick him to the curb when she finds out that he’s not up to her standards.  Hides behind the ‘guise of standards and rules to separate herself from Rudy in the early part of the film.  But what goes around, comes around.  Rudy running past her in uniform and saying “Don’t I know you?”  Oh yeah, that’s Notre Dame passing by Michigan in the standings and then leaving them in the dust for the ACC-slate of games and cancelling their annual series.  Wipe that smirk from your face!

John Ruettiger – Lane Kiffin:  Somewhat detached from the lead story and seems aloof for no apparent reason.  Oh heck, the real reason is when I asked myself the question:  “Who is the most likely person to start dating an old girlfriend, marry her, and knock her up all without telling Rudy?” the first name that came to mind was Lane Kiffin. 

Sherry - Urban Meyer: (from BH) Rudy's first love interest. The same love interest that left him when he finally decided to chase his dream, when he needed her most. She believed in Rudy and put in her time with him. Urban coached at ND under Lou Holtz. She wanted Rudy to buy a house, her dream house. ND wanted Meyer to rebuild a House, his dream House. When Rudy was at his lowest, she bailed on him. When ND was at its (then) lowest point, Meyer chose Florida instead of ND. Rudy didn't need Sherry to realize his dream. ND doesn't need Meyer, either.

Jamie O’Hara - Vince Vaughn: (from BH) Like O'Hara, Vince could have been one of the all time greats. Then he went and starred in "The Watch." I don't care if that movie was funny, nor do I have any idea if it was because I didn't waste my time. Ara didn't waste his time on O'Hara. In the end, though, O'Hara goes and does Rudy a solid and makes the play that gets Rudy in the game. Vaughn goes out of his way for ND, too, by showing up and killing it on College Gameday. 

Dan Devine - Joe Montana: (from BH, subject to better suggestions) Dan Devine came to ND in high regard. Joe Montana always comes to ND in maybe the highest regard. The first Rudy was told he would dress until Devine nixed that idea. Rudy Golson was told that he was going to be the starter, and Mr. Comeback had to go and rain on that parade by saying he was the least talented thrower on our team. With Rudy Golson leading the charge in a storybook season, maybe Montana will come around like Coach Devine did all those years ago. 


Still taking casting auditions for:

Jim:

In the meantime, go Irish!

Instant Reaction: God Likes Us (Notre Dame v. Pitt)


Notre Dame almost (spelled:  “should have”) been out Notre Dame’d tonight.  There was not much pretty about this game.  Tonight (spelled:  “today”) was supposed to be the beginning of a series of three games that Notre Dame was heavily favored in and won.  Instead, the Irish played down to their opponent and let some big plays nearly doom them.  Yes, this was a “game of destiny” for Notre Dame.  They should have lost.  This is the type of game that makes every analyst and every fan of another team root against us.  And yet, the Irish remain undefeated.  Perhaps we should just get off our pulpits and embrace the notion of “team of destiny.”  As a starter, let’s take a look at the normal stats:

Team:
ND:
Pitt:
First Downs:
34
13
Third Down Conversions:
10/20 = 50%
1/14 = 7%
Fourth Down Conversions:
1/1
0/1
Passing Yards:
291
164
Rushing Yards:
231
144
Total Yards:
522
308
Penalties:
6 – 46 yards
7 – 45 yards
Time of Possession:
35:23
24:37

If you looked at these numbers, I think most would agree that Notre Dame won the game…and by a large margin.  The superficial stats just do not give this game justice.  There are a couple of other categories to look at:

Team:
ND:
Pitt:
Turnovers:
3
0
Red Zone Attempts:
8
5
Red Zone Touchdowns:
3
2
Red Zone Field Goals:
3
2
Red Zone Scoring Percentgae:
75%
80%
Red Zone TD Percentage:
38%
40%

The fourth quarter and overtime mattered a lot to these numbers.  Notre Dame somehow overcame both a fourth quarter turnover and overtime turnover in the red zone to win this game.  What these metrics also show on the page is what all of us who watched this game live saw:  Pitt should have won.  Despite everything good that Notre Dame did, they consistently failed in some of the most important categories.  What’s shocking is the anomaly that this game provides.  Advanced metrics would suggest that Notre Dame both deserved to win this game easily (they were better from an efficiency standpoint), and they deserved to lose this game just as much (they were HORRIBLE in the most important sub-categories). 

I suppose “that’s why they play the games.”  This game embodied all of the drama that sports hope to encompass.  For my health, I pray they don’t continue this way.